Chelsea Player Statement
Eight Chelsea player makes the following statements :
1. Seven of us are lying here.
2. Six of us are lying here.
3. Five of us are lying here.
4. Five of us are lying here.
5. Four of us are lying here.
6. Three of us are lying here.
7. My name is Torres.
8. My name is Lampard.
The last two are Lampard and Torres or maybe Torres and Lampard.
So can you deduce which of the last two is Lampard or Torres?
Seventh one is Lampard and the eighth is Torres.
It is given that Persons seven and Eight are Torres and Lampard. So, we have only two possibilities:
P1. Person 7 is Torres and Person 8 is Lampard (i.e., exactly as they stated) OR
P2. Person 7 is Lampard and Person 8 is Torres
If P1 was correct, then both of them told the truth. In that case,
1. The first person’s statement “Seven of us are lying here” must be false (because two persons have told the truth)
2. If the second statement ‘Six of us are lying here’ were true, it implies that two persons told the truth (as already confirmed) and the rest lied. But then, the statement 2 also becomes true, thereby contradicting itself. Hence, the statement can’t be true.
3. Statement 3 could be true – i.e., five persons lied and rest three told the truth – the last two that are ‘confirmed’ as true plus the Person 3 himself.
4. Statement 4 is the same as Statement 3. Hence, if statement 3 were true, Statement 4 also must be true (being the same), but then the No. of true statements becomes 4 (two confirmed plus the statements 3 and 4), thereby contradicting the statement 3 (as well as 4). Hence, the statements must be false.
5. If Statement 5 – that four of them were lying, were true, all statements from 5 onwards must be true because we have already confirmed four preceding statements as false. However, Statement 6 can’t be true because it says three of them lied, whereas we have already confirmed four statements as false. This, in turn, implies that statement 5 also is wrong.
Thus, If P1 were correct, all other statements end up contradicting themselves, leaving only two statements true. But it would make the Statement 2 correct (i.e., six of them lied, which is already proven as self-contradictory. HENCE, P1 CAN’T BE TRUE.
Thus, P2 MUST BE correct. i.e., Person 7 is Lampard and Person 8 is Torres . In this case, both of them lied, thereby making the Statement 1 true – that seven of them (except Person 1 himself) were lying. Hence the result.
7th is Lampard and the 8th is Torres.
If we consider the statement “X of us are lying here” as “Exactly X of us are lying here” and there are only one player named Lampard and one player named Torres than statement (1) can be true so statements (7),(8) are false and therefore the person saying he is Torres is actually Lampard and vise versa.
Now lets see another approach:
Since statements (3) and (4) are the same than they both can be true or both false. So if they are both true that leaves only one more statements as true and since no other statement of the form: “X of us are lying here” can be true than means than only one of the statements (7), (8) is true and that is not an option so that means that statements (3) and (4) are False.
We know that statements (7), (8) can also both be true or both false.
If they are true than the options are :
>>>> 6 are lying > it contradicts with statement (2)
>>>> 5 are lying > it contradicts with statements (3) and (4)
>>>> 4,3 are lying means there are 2,3 more true statements but statements (1),(2),(5),(6) contradict between themselves so the only solution is that (7) and (8) are false and (1) is true.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
The Matchstick Riddle
Can you form five squares using six matchsticks ?Read More »Nine Letter Word
I know a nine-letter word having only one vowel. Do you?Read More »All is Right
A mathematician couple was having a Frappuccino in Starbucks sitting opposite to each other. Suddenly the guy noticed the text ...Read More »They are dark
They are Dark, and always on the run. without the sun, would be none.Read More »Fully grown beard in just small time
A man asked his wife if he could go to a friends party. His wife agreed, provided that he was ...Read More »Who is taller A or B?
500 men are arranged in an array of 10 rows and 50 columns according to their heights. Tallest among each ...Read More »Money packet Riddle
I have a large money box, 10 inches square and 12 inches tall. Roughly how many pennies can I place ...Read More »How can a man go eight days without sleep ?
How can a man go eight days without sleep ?Read More »Which are the requested two numbers. ?
Using the digits 1 up to 9, two numbers must be made. The product of these two numbers should be ...Read More »Rope can be stolen
If two fifty-foot ropes are suspended from a forty-foot ceiling that is twenty feet apart, how much rope will you ...Read More »Locked up in Jail
A father is locked up in jail. His wife has gone bankrupt. Their male child has to sell his hotel ...Read More »Can\’t be fired
What can not be burned in fire, nor drowned in water ?Read More »New York Traffic Laws puzzle
A bus driver was heading down a street in New York. He went right past a stop sign without stopping, ...Read More »Fuel in Car Race Riddle
Before the start of the car race, John and Jacob have the same amount of fuel in their car. With ...Read More »Orange Money Riddle
A man sees a sign that says ‘Oranges, $6 a dozen’. With his lightning quick brain he calculated that if ...Read More »Find the cat hiding in the kitchen
Who is alive and who is dead riddle
Fred, Bob and John stumble across a magic lamp. A genie pops out and grants them each the opportunity to ...Read More »Logical Algebra
Solve the equation by replacing the alphabet with numbers. MOM + MOM + NO = BOOK=Read More »The Gravity on Mars
Two Martians and two Earthlings traveling together came to a canal. As a result of the gravity on Mars, the ...Read More »Which number is hidden in the picture
There is a number hidden in the picture. Can you see or identify which number is hidden in the pictureRead More »