What are the two numbers puzzle?
Two positive integers < 50 are chosen.
The sum is revealed to A
The sum of the squares is revealed to B.
Both A and B are given the information in this problem.
The conversation between them goes as follows:
- B: I can’t tell what the numbers are
- A: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
- B: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
- A: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
- B: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
- A: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
- B: Now I can tell what the numbers are.
What are the two numbers?
This problem is intriguing!
Number the sentences in conversation:
<<1>> B: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
<<2>> A: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
<<3>> B: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
<<4>> A: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
<<5>> B: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
<<6>> A: I can’t tell what the numbers are.
<<7>> B: Now I can tell what the numbers are.
Denote the sum S and sum of squares N. S-list will be a list of all possible sums a + b, N-list a list of all possible sums of squares a^2 + b^2. Initially, the S-list contains all positive integers >1, N-list all positive integers expressible as sum of two positive integer squares.
The section <<i>> below describes the information gained after the line <<i>> in the conversation was spoken.
<<1>> N is not expressible as the sum of positive integer squares uniquely. N-list is correspondingly adjusted (numbers expressible as sum of two positive integer squares uniquely are thrown out). S-list is adjusted – sums are thrown out, that don’t allow for summands a, b, such that a^2 + b^2 is on the current N-list.
<<2>> S allows for more values of a, b (a + b = S), such that a^2 + b^2 belongs to the N-list. S-list is adjusted (sums are deleted not allowing for more values of a, b (a + b = the sum), such that a^2 + b^2 belongs to the N-list).
<<3>> N allows for more values of a, b (a^2 + b^2 = N), such that a + b is on the S-list. Those integers that don’t are deleted from the N-list.
<<4>> S allows for more values of a, b, such that a^2 + b^2 belongs to the N-list. Those integers that don’t are deleted from the S-list.
<<5>> N allows for more values of a, b, such that a + b belongs to the S-list. Those integers that don’t are deleted from the N-list.
<<6>> S allows for more values of a, b, such that a^2 + b^2 belongs to the N-list. Those integers that don’t are deleted from the S-list.
<<7>> At this moment there is only one pair of positive integers a, b, such that a + b is on the S-list and a^2 + b^2 = N. If N-list contains more values, they need to be checked to see if they allow for unique solution.
If some bounds are imposed on a,b, I guess the solution could be found by computer or manual deleting from the S- and N-list. I haven’t really thought beyond this outline yet, at this moment solving the problem in full generality seems difficult… I’d love to see the intended solution.
SOURCE– http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/community/c146h150971
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Counting Legs of Animals in zoo Puzzle
A Leopard has four legs, a spider has eight legs and a cricket has six legs. The total number of ...Read More »8 6 13 8 Maths Whatsapp Puzzle
_ + _ = 8 + + _ + _ ...Read More »What does this say
What does below chemistry rebus means?Read More »Potato changes nationality riddle
When does an American/Indian Potato changes its nationality ?Read More »Covert 0 (Zero)
Can you convert the number zero(0) into a positive number using just one mathematical operator?Read More »Killing People and Punishment Puzzle
Why despite killing dozens of people Charley and Wilma were not punished?Read More »Swimming in the Lake Riddle
A famous swimmer can swim downstream in a lake in exactly 40 minutes with the lake current. He can swim ...Read More »Cow with rope
If a caw is tied to a piece of rope that is 5 m long, how can she reach a ...Read More »Game of Cards
13 decks of cards have been mixed. What is the minimum number of cards that must be taken out from ...Read More »Yesterday follows today
yesterday is always before today, but there is a place where yesterday always follows today. Where?Read More »Catch the liar
There are two beautiful yet remote islands in the south pacific. The Islanders born on one island always tell the ...Read More »Five digit riddle
Can you find a five digit number which when you place a 7 at the beginning to make a new ...Read More »Fruit Supply
A farmer in Benezuela owns a beautiful Mango tree. He supplies the fruit to a nearby grocery store. The store ...Read More »Circular path ridfdle
On a circular path two person are walking in anti direction. How many times they will cross each other in ...Read More »Date on Dice
There are two dice with empty faces in front of you and a marker. You can mark any number on ...Read More »Punishment to sibling riddle
John and his younger brother were fighting. Their father was tired of the fighting and decided to punish them by ...Read More »Lemon Tree Plantation Puzzle
A gardener planted the Lemon trees in a mathematical ordered way (i.e. he planted a tree in rows). He created ...Read More »Apple juice and bottle distribution math puzzle
You are distributing apple juice. There are 21 bottles in total out of which 7 are full, 7 half empty ...Read More »How does the man escape?
A man is trapped in a room. In the room their is a table, chair, 2 doors, and a small ...Read More »Find the weight
A pudding, when put into one of the pans of these scales, appeared to weigh four ounces more than nine elevenths of its ...Read More »