THE POTATO PARADOX
Imagine that a farmer has a sack containing 100 lbs of potatoes. The potatoes, he discovers, are comprised of 99% water and 1% solids, so he leaves them in the heat of the sun for a day to let the amount of water in them reduce to 98%. But when he returns to them the day after, he finds his 100 lb sack now weighs just 50 lbs. How can this be true? Well, if 99% of 100 lbs of potatoes is water then the water must weigh 99 lbs. The 1% of solids must ultimately weigh just 1 lb, giving a ratio of solids to liquids of 1:99. But if the potatoes are allowed to dehydrate to 98% water, the solids must now account for 2% of the weight—a ratio of 2:98, or 1:49—even though the solids must still only weigh 1lb. The water, ultimately, must now weigh 49lb, giving a total weight of 50lbs despite just a 1% reduction in water content. Or must it?
Although not a true paradox in the strictest sense, the counterintuitive Potato Paradox is a famous example of what is known as a veridical paradox, in which a basic theory is taken to a logical but apparently absurd conclusion.
There is no paradox here, or anything even close.
At 99 pounds water and 1 pound solids, the water is 99/(99+1) = 99% by weight of the potatoes.
Removing 1% of the water (0.99 pounds) makes the ratio of solids be 98.01/(98.01+1) = 98.99% by weight of the potatoes. (Or, removing water equivalent to 1% of the weight of the potatoes makes the ratio of solids be 98/(98+1) = 98.9899% by weight.) This amounts to reducing the quantity of water by 1% (or 1 pound), but reducing the ratio of the water by just 0.01% (or 0.010101…%).
The potential confusion results from linguistics, not math. It has to do with the two different uses of the word “percentage”.
Let’s look at another example. Let’s say that 99% of 100 people surveyed like ice cream, leaving one person (1%) of people that don’t like ice cream. To reduce the percentage of people that like ice cream to 98%, just 1% (one person) needs to join the group of people that don’t like ice cream, making 2% of people not like ice cream. However, if instead of an ice cream fan converting I simply eliminate one person that likes ice cream from the survey, instead of 2% of people not liking ice cream, there are just 1.01%.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
One Bulb with 3 Switches
You have 3 switches in a room. One of them is for a bulb in next room. You can not ...Read More »Gets up 180 times
A person gets up 180 times every night and sleeps for at least 7 hours at a time. Where does ...Read More »Tax Collection Custom
A research team went to a village somewhere between the jungles of Africa. Luckily for them, they reached the day ...Read More »How far does the dog travel in 1 hour?
The Puzzle: A girl, a boy, and a dog start walking down a road. They start at the same time, ...Read More »Switch Or Not
You are presented with three boxes. One of them has a red ball inside and the other two have a ...Read More »Light Bulbs
You are in a room that has 3 switches and a closed door. The switches control 3 light bulbs on ...Read More »White Box without Key Puzzle
I am a white box having no key or lid. Yet there is a golden treasure inside it. What Am ...Read More »What is H doing right now?
There are nine children in the house, and only them in the house so A is ironing B is watching ...Read More »1 dollar = 100 cent
1 dollar = 100 cent = 10 cent x 10 cent = 1/10 dollar x 1/10 dollar = 1/100 dollar ...Read More »Most unusual paragraph riddle
How quickly can you find out what is so unusual about it? It looks so ordinary you’d think nothing was ...Read More »How many houses did you count?
If you count 20 houses on your right going to the store and 20 houses on your left coming home, ...Read More »Fins and Feathers
Hostile members of the Uti, Grundi and Yomi groups were travelling to a conference. There were two members from each ...Read More »Animals in a Zoo
If a zookeeper had 100 pairs of animals in her zoo, and two pairs of babies are born for each ...Read More »Look as flat
It come across as flat, But theirs more to it than its surface; You climb its mountains from top to ...Read More »One means None
If you have three you have three, if you have two you have two and if you have one you ...Read More »only Fresh
It is the only vegetable or fruit that is never sold frozen, canned, processed, cooked, or in any other form ...Read More »Arrange the digits
Can you arrange the following figures in two groups of four figures each so that each group shall add to the ...Read More »Out of Group
Which of the following words don’t belong in the group and why? CORSET, COSTER, SECTOR, ESCORT, COURTSRead More »Good to eat
I walked through a field of wheat, I picked up something good to eat, It was white and had no ...Read More »Student’s Fun
Teacher ask the student ‘Why are you standing on that chair in music class ?’. what did student replied ?Read More »