The Thief in the Liars’ Club
A valuable painting was stolen from the Liars’ Club, but the police are having a hard time identifying the culprit because every statement made by a member of the Liars’ Club is false. Only four members visited the club on the day that the painting was stolen. This is what they told the police:
- Ann: None of us took the painting. The painting was here when I left.
- Bob: I arrived second. The painting was already gone.
- Chuck: I was the third to arrive. The painting was here when I arrived.
- Tom: Whoever stole the painting arrived before me. The painting was already gone.
Who of these four liars stole the painting?
Since every statement is false, let us convert them into true statements, and number each statement:
- Ann: 1) One of us took the painting. 2) The painting was gone when I left.
- Bob: 3) I arrived first, third, or fourth. 4) The painting was still here.
- Chuck: 5) I arrived first, second, or fourth. 6) The painting was gone when I arrived.
- Tom: 7) Whoever stole the painting arrived after me. 8) The painting was still here.
According to statement #7, Tom is not the thief. #8: Since the painting was there when Tom arrived, he could not have been the last to arrive. Tom must have gone there first, second, or third. #6: The painting was gone when Chuck was there, so he didn’t arrive first. #5: So Chuck got there second or fourth. #4 and #8: As two other members (Bob and Tom) arrived to see the painting, Chuck didn’t get there second, either. So Chuck arrived fourth. #3: This means Bob arrived first or third. #2: Since the painting was gone when Ann left, she didn’t arrive first. Otherwise, no member after her would have seen the painting. So Ann went there second or third and Chuck arrived fourth. But since two other members (Bob and Tom) saw the painting when they arrived, Ann didn’t go there second, either. So Ann arrived third. #3: Therefore, Bob arrived first, and Tom arrived second.
In summary, Bob arrived first. Tom got there next and the painting was still there, so Bob was not the thief, and neither was Tom. When Ann arrived, the painting was still there, but it was gone when she left. So Ann was the one who stole the painting. Chuck arrived last and discovered that the painting was gone.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Place the Balls
Can you place three balls such that the equation shown in the picture holds true?Read More »Who is Culprit
Mr. John was killed on Saturday after noon. In Police investigation, his butler said he was bathing. His wife said ...Read More »Cost of Fruits
At my favorite fruit stand, an orange costs 18, a pineapple costs 27, and a grape costs 15. Using the ...Read More »Ten Letter Word
I know a ten-letter word in the English language which can be typed using only the top rows of the ...Read More »Logic Dice Game
A solo dice game is played. In this game, upon each turn, a normal pair of dice is rolled and ...Read More »Never Touched
Often held but never touched, always wet but never rusts, often bites but seldom bit, to use it well you ...Read More »Make the equation true by only drawing a single straight line
Make this equation true. You may ONLY draw ONE, PERFECTLY straight line 5+5+5=550 There are 4 acceptable answers. You must ...Read More »Divide 30 by 1/2 and add ten Tricky Math Puzzle
Divide 30 by 1/2 and add ten. What is the answer?Read More »WHICH IS THE FAKE COIN
You have twelve coins. You know that one is fake. The only thing that distinguishes the fake coin from the ...Read More »Faulty Clock
A clock loses 10 minutes each hour. If the clock is set correctly at noon, what time is it when ...Read More »How many times with he have to paint?
John has been hired to paint the numbers 1 through 100 on 100 apartments. How many times with he have ...Read More »Why blonde cannot dial 911?
Why blonde cannot dial 911?Read More »Label the Box correctly
There are three boxes which are labeled as Rs100, Rs150, and Rs200. One box contains two notes of Rs. 50. ...Read More »Soldiers crossing river
An army general wanted ten soldiers to cross a river. There was no bridge and the soldiers could not swim. ...Read More »Petrol leakage riddle
I traveled from London to Glasgow last week at 60 miles per hour, I had filled my petrol tank just ...Read More »What day is tomorrow?
When the day after tomorrow is yesterday, today will be as far from Wednesday as today was from Wednesday when ...Read More »Born in Lahore
A Child was born in Lahore, Pakistan. Still child is not a Pakistani citizen. why ?Read More »Which is Odd One Out ?
Which is Odd One Out ? and why ? 4377 3954 9862 8454 9831Read More »Smuggling Between Boarder
John wakes up daily to pick up his cycle and crosses the border between Spain and France daily with a ...Read More »How did the robber want to die?
A robber tried to steal the crown jewels. He got caught by the King’s guards and was taken to the ...Read More »