The Alert Consumer
Food labels have a lot of technical information that is hard to interpret. We will compare the nutrition labels of raw sunflower seeds from two stores to try to figure out the differences. Weight ratios of fat, carbohydrate, and protein of 2:1:1 to 3:1:1 are very typical for nuts and oil seeds.
The most obvious discrepancy in these labels is the serving size of 28g for the Whole Foods seeds vs. 33g for the Trader Joe’s seeds, both of which have 190 Calories per serving. It is unlikely that a five-gram (15%) difference in the serving size would have a negligible effect on the total calories. We also notice that the Whole Foods seeds have three times the amount of fiber as the Trader Joe’s seeds, and Trader Joe’s seeds have no sugars whereas the Whole Foods seeds have 1 gram of sugars. Aren’t all sunflower seeds the same? How reliable are these “Nutrition Facts”?
Let us start with a simple check to see if everything adds up. The Whole Foods serving size is 28g, but if we add 17g of fat, 6g of carbohydrate, and 7g of protein the total is 30g. Oops! It is not unusual for the sum of the components to be slightly different than the whole due to rounding errors and unlisted components, but it is abnormal to have the components exceed the total serving size by 2 grams (7%).
The Trader Joe’s serving size is 33g. Adding 16g of fat, 8g of carbohydrate, and 8g of protein we get 32g. This is much more consistent and the discrepancy is probably due to rounding. If we had 16.3g of fat, 8.4g of carbohydrate, and 8.3g of protein everything would add up properly, but by rounding to whole numbers we would lose 3% precision.
How about the Calories? Fat has 9 Calories per gram, and protein and carbohydrate have 4 Calories per gram. Fiber contributes no calories because it cannot be digested, so we subtract the grams of fiber from the total carbohydrate. The remaining carbohydrates consist of sugars and starches. The Whole Foods seeds have 9×17 + 4×(6-3) + 4×7 = 193 Calories. The Calories from fat are 9×17 = 153. By rounding to the nearest ten, we get 190 total Calories and 150 Calories from fat in perfect agreement with the label.
Trader Joe’s seeds have 9×16 + 4×(8-1) + 4×8 = 204 Calories. The Calories from fat are 9×16 = 144. By rounding, we get 200 total Calories and 140 Calories from fat. Oops! Something is inconsistent. The total Calories calculated from the components is 5% larger than stated on the label, and the Calories from fat calculated from the components is 6% lower than on the label.
The % Daily Values are based on a U.S. government recommendation that 30% of the Calories should be from fat, 55% from carbohydrates, and 15% from protein. For a 2000-Calorie diet, this is equivalent to 67g of fat, 300g of carbohydrate that includes 25g of dietary fiber, and 75g of protein per day. The dietary fiber for the Whole Foods seeds should be 3×100/25 = 12% instead of 13%. Trader Joe’s Total Fat should be 16×100/67 = 24% instead of 25%, and the dietary fiber value should be 1×100/25 = 4% instead of 5%. These differences are not significant.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Translation error in a cookbook
Recently, I received a wonderful cookbook. In an appendix, it shows a table that converts oven temperatures between Celsius and ...Read More »Filling 9 gallons riddle
Using a water tap, a 07 gallon container and a 11 gallon container, can you measure exactly 9 gallons? You ...Read More »Move just one matchstick to fix the equation 6+4=4
Move just One matchstick to fix the equation. This math question seems simple, however, there are multiple solutions. Read More »High or Low
Each of the clues below refers to a five-letter word that contains either ‘HI’ or ‘LO’ within it. Can you ...Read More »No Objection
Not a single parent objected when the teacher spanked every child in the class. How come?Read More »Count The Square
Can you count the number of squares in the given picture?Read More »New your city hair count bet
You are visiting New York City when a man approaches you. \”Not counting bald people, I bet a hundred bucks ...Read More »Geographical family
A cloud was my mother, the wind is my father, my son is the cool stream, and my daughter is ...Read More »Smoking cigarettes Puzzles
One man has a habit of smoking cigarettes regularly. He has a strange habit of smoking even filters of the ...Read More »Maths Aptitude Puzzle
Find the next number in the series 12, 20, 40, 72, 116, 172 ?Read More »Spiral to Square Puzzle
Move three sticks of the spiral below to form a square.Read More »People in the Hotel
10 people came into a hotel with 9 rooms and each guest wanted his own room. The bellboy solved this ...Read More »Noblest musical instrument
What is the noblest musical instrument ?Read More »One colour but not one size riddle
He has one colour, but not one size, Stuck at the bottom, yet easily flies. Present in sun, but not ...Read More »You stand at a fork in the road?
You stand at a fork in the road. Next to each of the two forks, there stands a guard. You ...Read More »You can’t find out!!!
Fariha, Ononno, Richie each got a prime. Suppose the numbers are A,B,C. They permute the numbers in the following possible ...Read More »How does he know what is inside the box?
A man walks into a completely dark room. There is a box on a table at the other end of ...Read More »Multiplication puzzle
Multiple by 8 without using multiplication or addition Now do the same with 7?Read More »1-40 litres of milk in drum
There is a drum full of milk, people come for buying milk in the range of 1-40 litres. You can ...Read More »Dangerous Jungle
A man and his wife were doing missionary work near the city of Nairobi in the country of Kenya in ...Read More »