Color of the hat puzzle
Four men walk into the desert. Suddenly all four are simultaneously knocked out. They awake buried to their heads in the sand unable to look anywhere but straight ahead. They are positioned so that each man sees another’s head before him. However between the first and second man there is a separating wall. So the first man sees only desert. The second man sees only wall. The third man sees another’s head and a wall. The fourth man sees two heads and a wall. On top of each mans head is a hat. The underside of each cap is black, but the outside of each cap is either blue or white. Before any of the men can speak, their captors tell them if they speak, they die. However, if any of them can guess the color of their cap on the first try they go free. The captors tell them that there are two blue caps and two white caps. Being an omniscient observer of the situation, we know that the order of the caps are: blue, white, blue, white. So knowing the perspective of each man in the sand, and that they can only see the color of caps/wall/desert in front of them, which of the four men knows for certain the color of his own cap. More importantly: why?
The third man. This is because he knows there are only two of each color cap. If the man behind him (the fourth man) saw two caps that were the same color in front of him, he would know that his own must be the opposite. However, because the caps alternate in color. The fourth man has only a 50% chance of getting his hat color correct, so therefore he stays quiet. The third man realizes that the fourth man is quiet because he must not see two caps of the same color in front of him, otherwise the fourth man would say the opposite of the caps in front of him. Therefore, the third man presumes his own cap must be the opposite of the mans in front of him, and his presumption is correct. Under this same logic, after the third man speaks his color hat, the second man, even though he sees only wall, would be the next to go free, because he knows his cap must be the opposite of whichever color the third mans cap was.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
How many children do i have puzzle
My daughter has many sisters. She has as many sisters as she has brothers. Each of her brothers has twice ...Read More »The Box with Ball
There are three bags.The first bag has two blue rocks. The second bag has two red rocks. The third bag ...Read More »Distance Covered
Two Twins Jack and Jill were standing back to back and suddenly they started running in opposite direction for 4 ...Read More »Nobody in back
Look in my face, I am somebody; Look in my back, I am nobody. What am I ?Read More »How did he know?
A man orders a coffee and finds a fly in it. He sends it back and gets another one. But ...Read More »Why did the jury convict him?
A man is in court for killing his wife. In the closing statements the man’s lawyer surprises everyone when he ...Read More »On which day does Suarez tell the truth?
Suarez is a strange liar. He lies on six days of the week, but on the seventh day he always ...Read More »Combination of bags
A man went into a bank with a thousand dollars, all in dollar bills, and ten bags. He said, “Place ...Read More »What is the least number of eggs he needs for this to be true?
John has some chickens that have been laying him plenty of eggs. He wants to give away his eggs to ...Read More »Climbing mountain midnight to midnight puzzle
If a mountain climber climbed up a mountain one day from midnight to midnight the next day and does the ...Read More »What would you have?
If you had three apples and four oranges in one hand and four apples and three oranges in the other ...Read More »Solve the Mystery
A man is found dead with a knife in his back When the investigation is done. A chair lays beside ...Read More »What are the sons’ ages?
John has sons. His eldest son is four years older than his second son. The second son is four years ...Read More »What is it puzzle
Who makes it, has no need of it. Who buys it, has no use for it. Who uses it can ...Read More »What is highest number of apples you can get to Bananaville?
You have been given the task of transporting 3,000 apples 1,000 miles from Appleland to Bananaville. Your truck can carry ...Read More »Swimmer dies in the Jungle
A guy in his thirties is found dead in a forest. The shocking thing about the body is that he ...Read More »Cheapest word processor riddle
Last week I bought a word processor small enough to fit in my pocket. It can write in any language ...Read More »School Inspector and Teacher
An inspection by the superintendent of St. Joseph School was scheduled on the next day. The class teacher Jenifer knew ...Read More »Women and Fish lateral thinking puzzle
A woman had a pet goldfish which she loved very dearly. One day she noticed that it was swimming feebly ...Read More »My two tell you who I am
I am 5 letters long. My first two tell you who I am My first 3 could be a medicine ...Read More »