Horse Race Puzzle
There are 25 horses among which you need to find out the fastest 3 horses. You can conduct race among at most 5 horses in a single race to find out their relative speed. At no point you can find out the actual speed of the horse in a race. Find out minimum number of races are required to find the 3 horses.
The answer is 7 .Here’s how :
Divide the horses into group of 5 (A,B,C,D,E) and conduct 5 races to find 5 fastest horses .
Now conduct a race among these to find the fastest horse (Let’s say it’s from group E) .and let’s also assume that fastest horse from group D came 2nd and C came 3rd. Total 6 races done. Now the second fastest horse can be the one who came second in the group E which gave us the fastest horse or the one which came second in 6th race. Similarly the 3rd fastest horse can be
the either fastest horse from group D and C ,or the horses which came 2nd and 3rd in group E or the horse which came second in group D. Conduct a race among these 5 horses and you will get the result in final and 7th race.
My answer is 11.
First you split the 25 horses into 5 groups of 5. The puzzle tells us that we can’t measure speed, only relative speed, so we can’t compare horses across races. Thus, we have to take the top 3 horses of each race. (5 races)
Next, we have 15 horses so we split them into 3 groups of 5. We again take the top 3 of each group. (3 races)
Then, from the remaining 9, we form one group of 5 and take the top 3, adding it to the remaining 4. (1 race)
Now we have 7 remaining, we form another group of 5 and take the top 3, adding it to the remaining 2. (1 race)
We now have 5 horses left and we can form our top 3 in this final race. (1 race)
Add them up and you’ve got 11 races.
The reason I disagree with the first answer:
Imagine a scenario where 3 horses of race #2 are faster than the fastest horse of race #1. You’ve eliminated the 2nd and 3rd fastest horses.
You have to assume the horses will not tire, which is not realistic. Any way, you would race horse # 1 with horse # 2 and the winner would race horse #3. The winner of that race then races horse #4. And so on down the line until horse # 25 races. Minimum # of races is 26.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Fruit Selling Rate
John is selling fruits. He sells grapes at $30, Dates $25, and a Wolfberry $45. At what price does he ...Read More »Burning house rescue within time riddle
Group of friends are trapped in a burning house. The house is going to collapse in 12 minutes so they ...Read More »Time in the Clock
What Time Should the last watch show in the below figure?Read More »What day is tomorrow?
When the day after tomorrow is yesterday, today will be as far from Wednesday as today was from Wednesday when ...Read More »Four People on a Rickety Bridge
Four people need to cross a rickety bridge at night. Unfortunately, they have only one torch and the bridge is ...Read More »Rich River Puzzle
Why is a river so rich ?Read More »Have horn but Can\’t Beep Riddle
It has horns but can’t beep. It is like to bleat but It is not a sheep. What is it?Read More »Crack the Cipher
The following “Brain Bat” means Slow Down. S L O W Using the same logic, can you tell us what ...Read More »Clock Needles Overlapping
I have a clock(12-hour format) and both the needles of the clock overlap at 12:00. After how much time, they ...Read More »What happened to Angel and Dory
Angel and Dory were found on the ground gasping for air surrounded by glass and water. The person who found ...Read More »Card Probability
What’s the probability of getting a king or a queen from a pack of 52 cards?Read More »Proposing a blind deaf dumb girl puzzle
A girl is blind, deaf, dumb and uneducated too. A boy loves her. How would he propose without touching her?Read More »London in Brazil
Which part of London is in Brazil ?Read More »Murder Mystery Riddle
One evening there was a murder in the home of a married couple, their son and daughter. One of these ...Read More »All have me
When you have me not, you want me. But when you have me, you do not know. What am I?Read More »Fish Story
There are 5 houses of 5 different colours. One person of a different nationality lives in each house. The 5 ...Read More »The yolk of the egg is white
Which is correct to say, The yolk of the egg are white, or The yolk of the egg is white ...Read More »Beware Pickpockets lateral thinking puzzle
A pickpocket, before starting his work, places a sign board in front of a shop which reads “Beware Pickpockets!”. Why ...Read More »Popular Probability Puzzle
This is a popular probability puzzle in which you have to select the correct answer at random from the four ...Read More »Pictures to Identify
Identify the ten differences between the two given pictures below.Read More »