THE FLETCHER’S PARADOX
Imagine a fletcher (i.e. an arrow-maker) has fired one of his arrows into the air. For the arrow to be considered to be moving, it has to be continually repositioning itself from the place where it is now to any place where it currently isn’t. The Fletcher’s Paradox, however, states that throughout its trajectory the arrow is actually not moving at all. At any given instant of no real duration (in other words, a snapshot in time) during its flight, the arrow cannot move to somewhere it isn’t because there isn’t time for it to do so. And it can’t move to where it is now, because it’s already there. So, for that instant in time, the arrow must be stationary. But because all time is comprised entirely of instants—in every one of which the arrow must also be stationary—then the arrow must in fact be stationary the entire time. Except, of course, it isn’t.
While it may be true that the arrow doesn’t change its position ‘during’ the instant it does definitely still have a velocity, only you cannot observe that by just looking at a snapshot. But that doesn’t mean it’s not there.
An explanation might be that “moving” is not defined very clearly. If you rephrase the word “moving” and use the word “velocity” instead, the paradox immediately breaks down:
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Never Touched
Often held but never touched, always wet but never rusts, often bites but seldom bit, to use it well you ...Read More »I take what you receive
I take what you receive and surrender it all by waving my flag.What am I?Read More »Head Tail Puzzle
As it often happens in life evil warlock imprisoned a wise man. Surprisingly he gave him a chance to save ...Read More »Bulb and switch riddle
You are in a room with three light switches, each of which controls one of three light bulbs in the ...Read More »Who did?
Wednesday, Tom and Joe went to a restaurant and ate dinner. When they were done they paid for the food ...Read More »Rectifying a pill mistake
A man has a medical condition that requires him to take two kinds of pills, call them A and B. ...Read More »What is the phrase?
What is the word or phrase?Read More »Canola oil and olive oil mixture
While shopping for groceries, you notice a new cooking oil product consisting of a blend of canola oil and olive ...Read More »Card Trick Riddle
I ask Alex to pick any 5 cards out of a deck with no Jokers. He can inspect then shuffle ...Read More »Belongs to me
It belongs to you, but other people use it more than you do. What is it?Read More »Who am I?
I have no voice yet I speak to you, I tell of all things in the world that people do. ...Read More »Crossing Bridge Interview Puzzle
Four people are on this side of the bridge. the bridge will be destroyed by a bomb in 17 minutes. ...Read More »Connecting 9 dots with 4 line puzzle
Look at the 9 dots in this image. Can you draw 4 straight lines, without picking up your pen, that ...Read More »What 2 things you can’t eat for breakfast?
What 2 things you can’t eat for breakfast? It’s logicRead More »Crossing a River Riddle
John and Jacob want to cross a river. The only way to get to the other side of the river ...Read More »Think with mind riddle
It is a surprise! It is a miracle! It sprouted without a seed, It stood without a trunk. Think it ...Read More »Identical Cats Puzzle
Out of the nine cats that you can see in the picture, there are only two that are completely identical. ...Read More »APPLY LOGIC NOT MATHEMATICS
Amanda dies and reaches at the gate of heaven. She has three doors in front of her out of which ...Read More »Wife murder investigation puzzle
A man murders his wife with a knife in their car. Nobody is around to see this. He throws her ...Read More »Wife shoot her husband puzzle
A woman shoots her husband, then holds him under water for five minutes. A little while later, they both go ...Read More »
