# Boolean Enlightenment

1,476.2K Views

The path to enlightenment lies behind one of two doors. In front of each door stands a guard who knows which door leads to enlightenment, but one of the guards always lies and the other one always tells the truth. In your search for enlightenment, you are allowed to ask one guard only one question that can be answered “yes” or “no”, but unfortunately, you do not know which guard is the liar. You will be banished to the dungeon of logical illiteracy if you fail in your quest. What question should you ask to find the path to enlightenment?

pnikam Expert Asked on 17th August 2015 in

If you ask a guard directly “Are you guarding the path to enlightenment?”, and the answer is “no”, he could be guarding the path to enlightenment and be lying about it, or he could be telling the truth and the path to enlightenment is behind the other door.

The question that you ask has to involve both guards at the same time:

“Would the other guard say that you are guarding the path to enlightenment?”When we ask a guard this question, there are 4 cases:

1. The liar is guarding the path to enlightenment. He answers “no” because the truthful guard would say “yes”.
2. The liar is not guarding the path to enlightenment: He answers “yes” because the truthful guard would say “no”.
3. The truth teller is guarding the path to enlightenment. He answers “no” because the other guard (liar) would say “no”.
4. The truth teller is not guarding the path to enlightenment. He answers “yes” because the other guard (liar) would say “yes”.

So, if a guard answers “no”, he is guarding the path to enlightenment. If he answers “yes”, the path to enlightenment is the other door. Notice that even though we have learned which is the path to enlightenment, we still don’t know which guard is the liar. To find out who is the liar we would have to ask a question like: “Would the other guard say that you always tell the truth?” A reply of “no” means you are talking to the truth teller, a reply of “yes” means you are talking to the liar.

anikam Expert Answered on 17th August 2015.

• ## More puzzles to try-

• ### Find the number of animals and their kind

My friend who owns a farm near Bangalore has five droves of animals on his farm consisting of cows, sheep ...Read More »
• ### How it is possible?

There are two friends. Andrew is standing behind Bravo and at the same time Bravo is standing behind Andrew. How ...Read More »
• ### Move six matchsticks to make 5 squares

In the given figure you have to move six matchsticks such that the resulting figure has five squares. Move it, ...Read More »
• ### Picture sent to jail riddle

Why was the picture sent to jail ?Read More »
• ### Vacation at cousin’s place puzzle

It was vacation time,  So I decided to visit my cousin’s home. What a grand time we had! In the ...Read More »
• ### Closed Room Riddle

You are in a room that is completely bricked in on all four sides, including the ceiling and floor. You ...Read More »
• ### Four People on a Rickety Bridge

Four people need to cross a rickety bridge at night. Unfortunately, they have only one torch and the bridge is ...Read More »
• ### Wise Woman riddle

A wealthy wise old woman feared that her son was lazy and as a result rather stupid. When the old ...Read More »
• ### Fly Catchers

What has 18 legs and catches flies?Read More »
• ### Fishing Rod riddle

Using the Puzzlefry E-commerce solution, Jacob ordered a fishing rod, priced at \$6.36. Unfortunately, Jacob is an fisherman who lives ...Read More »
• ### Maths equation Puzzle

5+3+2 = 151022 9+2+4 = 183652 8+6+3 = 482466 5+4+5 = 202541 THEN ; 7+2+5 =?Read More »
• ### Alphabetical Puzzle

I know a number which is spelt in alphabetical order. Do you?Read More »
• ### never rude for you

I never be rude for you, Though I flag my tongue for all to see. Who am I?Read More »
• ### Wine Glass Stem

Why Wine Glass Stem is so long?Read More »
• ### Would there be a time at which he was at the same position

If a mountain climber climbed up a mountain one day from midnight to midnight the next day and does the ...Read More »
• ### Strong Lions Riddle

Rearrange all the letters in each of the sentences to form, in each case, a well known proverb. 1. I ...Read More »
• ### Solve by Name Puzzle

Solve the puzzle by telling what does below picture means.Read More »
• ### Desired by all

It is desired by all, yet hard to find. You can search endlessly, but have little peace of mind. What ...Read More »