Why did the jury convict him?
A man is in court for killing his wife. In the closing statements the man’s lawyer surprises everyone when he announces “His wife was just missing. Everyone look at those doors. His wife is going to walk in those doors in about 30 seconds.”The entire court is silent and the jury stares at the door as the lawyer and the defendant stare at them. After a couple of minutes the lawyer says “See! If you were so sure he killed his wife, you wouldn’t be watching that door!”The jury goes into deliberation and comes back almost immediately with a guilty verdict.Why did the jury convict him?
The defendant (guilty man) wasn’t looking at the door. He knew his wife wasn’t coming.
The answer given by ‘silent47’ is surely logical, but…
Consider the scenario where the defendant didn’t kill his wife, but, as a matter of fact, is very much aware that she’s actually dead (might have been killed by somebody else). The lawyer, in a last-ditch effort to save his / her client, attempts to play the ‘doubt factor’ and makes the statement presented in the question. In this scenario, the defendant knows for certain that his wife isn’t coming, and hence won’t look at the door for the ‘dead woman walking’. In this scenario, the jury’s ‘guilty’ verdict would amount to gross miscarriage of justice.
Now, consider another angle: The defendant is actually guilty. The lawyer, aware that any statement (s)he makes in the Court is binding on the defendant, wouldn’t make any statement / claim without having consulted him beforehand. Had the lawyer discussed the ploy (of making the jury doubtful) with the defendant, (s)he would have trained the defendant to play his part in the Court room ‘drama’. (Otherwise, the whole ploy is useless.) In such a scenario, the defendant would have looked at the door as well and the sequence of events presented in the question couldn’t have arisen.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
FIND THE CULPRIT
Andrew Richardson, deputy head cryptographer at a top department of defence (DOD) facility, was working late one night. The last ...Read More »Petrol leakage riddle
I traveled from London to Glasgow last week at 60 miles per hour, I had filled my petrol tank just ...Read More »Women and Men both do once in Lifetime Puzzle
Women do it once a year after they turn 19 but men get to do it only once in a ...Read More »Smiling Guards Puzzle
Two guards were on duty outside a barracks. One faced up the road to watch for anyone approaching from the ...Read More »Solve the Equation
1 + 9 + 8 = ? considering, 28 + 8 + 92 = 10Read More »Fully grown beard in just small time
A man asked his wife if he could go to a friends party. His wife agreed, provided that he was ...Read More »Women and Fish lateral thinking puzzle
A woman had a pet goldfish which she loved very dearly. One day she noticed that it was swimming feebly ...Read More »How will you program it to work?
The LCD device should be able to tell the right time in the format HH:MM:SS in 12-hour format. You can ...Read More »Fill the Required Number Puzzle
Replace the question mark in the picture below.Read More »People and Bed
Why do people go to bed?Read More »Bathe in hot water
It often bathes in hot water in the morning. Its essence goes through its clothes. Used up is it; it ...Read More »How many children does Mr. Smith have?
Mr. Smith has 4 daughters. Each of his daughters has a brother. How many children does Mr. Smith have?Read More »See beyond me
Almost everyone sees me without noticing me, For what is beyond is what they seek. What am I?Read More »What’s made of wood?
What’s made of wood but can’t be sawed?Read More »What is the probability that it was a penny?
Mary had a coin purse with fifty coins, totaling exactly $1.00. Unfortunately, while counting her change, she dropped one coin. ...Read More »Always Ahead
It is always ahead of me yet I can never see it. What is it?Read More »Five pieces of chain to make a long chain riddle
You have five pieces of chain, each consisting of three links. You want to make one long chain of these ...Read More »You look directly at the intersection, the grey dots will disappear.
mall grey dots should appear at the intersections of the squares, but if you look directly at the intersection, the ...Read More »Cost than riches
What costs more than riches but does not cost a penny; that is also hard to find yet easy to ...Read More »Alphabet Letter Riddle
Which alphabet letter is a question?Read More »
