# Treasure in gold and silver pot puzzle

1,090.4K Views

There is a silver pot and a golden pot. One of these pots contains a treasure and the other one is empty.
Both of them have a label containing hints. Assume that you can determine from the labels which pot contains the treasure.

The labels on the pots are the following:
The silver pot: “This pot is empty.”
The golden pot: “Exactly one of these texts is true.”

SherlockHolmes Expert Asked on 30th August 2016 in

Answer – The Silver Pot contains the treasure

The statements:
(S) The silver pot: “This pot is empty.”
(G) The golden pot: “Exactly one of these texts is true.”

Premise: Let S be TRUE:

Assumption 1: ‘G’ is also true

This will contradict itself, because , as per the statement, only one of S / G can be true AND S is already true, which implies that G must be false, contradicting the assumption.

Assumption 2: G is False

Then either BOTH S and G should be TRUE OR both should be false. But since our premise is that S is true, this means G also must be true, again contradicting the assumption.

Thus, both the scenarios end up self-contradictory, which, in turn, implies that our premise must be wrong. So, ‘S’ must be false.

Then, G can be true, because only one statement (G) is true.

Hence the result: The label on silver pot is wrong => It is NOT  empty => contains the treasure.

Viji_Pinarayi Expert Answered on 30th August 2016.

Silver contains treasure

aurora Starter Answered on 4th September 2016.

• ## More puzzles to try-

• ### How many children do i have puzzle

My daughter has many sisters. She has as many sisters as she has brothers. Each of her brothers has twice ...Read More »
• ### Stabilizing nodes from an anchor

In a finite, undirected, connected graph, an integer variable v(n) is associated with each node n.  One node is distinguished ...Read More »
• ### I can guide you

I am so simple, that I can only point yet I guide men all over the world.Read More »
• ### Which clock works best?

Which clock works best? The one that loses a minute a day or the one that doesn’t work at all?Read More »

• ### Nose and Feet

Why are the nose and feet confusing body parts?Read More »
• ### implement isPalindrome(int n)

Implement the function boolean isPalindrome (int n); Which will return true if the bit-wise representation of the integer is a ...Read More »
• ### Two consecutive numbers thinking puzzle

A professor thinks of two consecutive numbers between 1 and 10. ‘A’ knows the 1st number and ‘B’ knows the ...Read More »

• ### Wise Son

An old man wanted to leave all of his money to one of his three sons, but he didn’t know ...Read More »
• ### Seen in the sky

It is seen in the water, if seen in the sky, It is in the rainbow, a jay’s feather and ...Read More »
• ### Microwave for just 2 seconds riddle

Mark, the lazy guy puts his coffee into the microwave, as he does every morning, for exactly 2 minutes. When ...Read More »
• ### What’s her name?

A smooth dance, a ball sport, a place to stay, an Asian country, and a girl’s name. What’s her name?Read More »
• ### Ishan Dictation test riddle

Little Ishan was a very bad at memorizing word spellings and he regularly makes mistake. So his teacher comes up ...Read More »
• ### Count the Squares

Count the squares in the matchstick puzzle below?Read More »
• ### Birth Day Riddle

John was born on March 5, 1970, in Delhi, India. Jacob was born 25 days before John. The year when ...Read More »
• ### What is the fastest way to empty the bathtub?

You fill up a bathtub with water and you have a teaspoon, tablespoon, and fourth cup. What is the fastest ...Read More »
• ### 1 to 9 all digits to be used puzzle

Use digits from 1 to 9 once in such a way that each digit is used in the boxes and ...Read More »
• ### cat & mice on chessboard riddle

Four white pieces (the mice) are placed on one side of a chessboard, and one black piece (the cat) is ...Read More »