Voting on how to distribute coins
100 coins are to be distributed among some number of persons, referred to by the labels A, B, C, D, …. The distribution works as follows. The person with the alphabetically highest label (for example, among 5 people, E) is called the chief. The chief gets to propose a distribution of the coins among the persons (for example, chief E may propose that everyone get 20 coins, or he may propose that he get 100 coins and the others get 0 coins). Everyone (including the chief) gets to vote yes/no on the proposed distribution. If the majority vote is yes, then that’s the final distribution. If there’s a tie (which there could be if the number of persons is even), then the chief gets to break the tie. If the majority vote is no, then the chief gets 0 coins and has to leave the game, the person with the alphabetically next-highest name becomes the new chief, and the process to distribute the 100 coins is repeated among the persons that remain. Suppose there are 5 persons and that every person wants to maximize the number of coins that are distributed to them. Then, what distribution should chief E propose?
Answer:
A-10
B-10
C-30
D-30
E-20
If he proposes equal distribution rest all will refuse so that if E leaves they can get more money.
So the above given distribution is the best.
A and B will refuse.
If D refuses, E leaves. then D will have to propose.
To stay safe he needs at least one more vote, then he’ll break the tie.
at the most he can safely propose :
A-20
B-20
C-30
D-30
if he takes any more all others will definitely refuse and he won’t get anything.
So, there’s no point in D refusing to E’s proposal.
if C is given more than what D gets, he might refuse on account of jealousy!!
though C might refuse, this is the safest possible distribution that E can come up with.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Four Nines Equal Hundred
Can you make four (4) nines (9) equal 100?Read More »Average clan size
The people in a country are partitioned into clans. In order to estimate the average size of a clan, a ...Read More »Look as flat
It come across as flat, But theirs more to it than its surface; You climb its mountains from top to ...Read More »A Girl with Her Large Family
There’s a girl who has a large family. She has an equal amount of brothers and sisters, but each brother ...Read More »What happens when you throw a blue rock into the yellow sea?
What happens when you throw a blue rock into the yellow sea?Read More »Bottom at the top
What has a bottom at the top?Read More »Commander order
A group of soldiers were standing in the blistering sun facing west. Their commander shouted at them: Right turn! About ...Read More »father and son question
if there are 1 son 1 father and 1 grandfather how many sons are thereRead More »Polar Bear riddle
You are on holidays and wake up in the morning, stand up, and look South. You look to the left ...Read More »Famous puzzle by Sam Lloyd issued in 1882. Want to try?
The Puzzle: Here is a famous prize problem that Sam Loyd issued in 1882, offering $1000 as a prize for ...Read More »What am I?
If you look, you can’t see me. If you see me, you cannot see anything else. I can make you ...Read More »What are you to shakira?
If shakira’s daughter is your daughter’s mother, what are you to shakira?Read More »Find The Ages
Jenifer and Jesica are having a conversation. Jenifer: I am definitely not over 30. Jesica: I am 28 and you ...Read More »Food Cooked inside
My favourite food is one you throw out the outside and cook the inside. what food is it ?Read More »Minimum Number of Weigths
A wholesale merchant came to me one day and posed this problem. Every day in his business he has to ...Read More »Solve This Picture Riddle
Fish without an eye riddle
What do you call a fish without an eye?Read More »Can you calculate how long would it have taken to be filled half?
A large container is kept in open under the rain. Every passing hour, the water collected inside the container becomes ...Read More »Gaggle of geese riddle
Starting with a five letter word, change one letter to create a new word. This word is then changed by ...Read More »Hard Number Series Puzzle
What number comes next in the series? 5 15 5 18 5 24 14 20 _Read More »