# Can you determine who stole the cake?

1,166.3K Views

During a recent police investigation, Chief Inspector of PuzzleFry was interviewing five local villains to try and identify who stole Mrs Riddle’s cake from the mid-summers fayre. Below is a summary of their statements:

Arnold:  it wasn’t Edward
it was Brian

Brian:   it wasn’t Charles
it wasn’t Edward

Charles: it was Edward
it wasn’t Arnold

Derek:   it was Charles
it was Brian

Edward:  it was Derek
it wasn’t Arnold

It was well known that each suspect told exactly one lie. Can you determine who stole the cake?

SherlockHolmes Expert Asked on 24th July 2015 in

Charles committed the theft.

Looking at Brian’s statements, one of the statements was a lie and the other was the truth. Therefore it must have been either Charles or Edward.
Looking at Derek’s statements, for the same reason, it was either Charles or Brian.

Therefore it must have been Charles who committed the crime. Double checking this against the other statements confirms this.

neha Expert Answered on 24th July 2015.

• ## More puzzles to try-

• ### Left Hand Riddle

What can you hold in your left hand but can never hold in your right hand?Read More »
• ### Oil Smuggling case puzzle

A detective who was mere days away from cracking an international oil smuggling ring has suddenly gone missing. While inspecting ...Read More »
• ### Time puzzle

Supposing a clock takes 7 seconds to strike 7, how long does it take for the same clock to strike ...Read More »
• ### Convicts in Jail riddle

There are two convicts locked in a cell. There is an unbarred window high up in the cell. They can ...Read More »
• ### What is common here

What is common among 11, 69, and 88?Read More »
• ### Who am I??

I’m number three. But I’m not a number. I’m hot and cold at the same moment but not at the ...Read More »
• ### Dogs and Cats

All of Mrs. John pets are dogs except one, and all her pets are cats except one. How many cats ...Read More »
• ### Who will get the banana first

A monkey, a squirrel, and a bird are racing to the top of a coconut tree. Who will get the ...Read More »
• ### What is his age

When Jacob is twice as old as John, Then I shall be just 17. But Jaco was 23 When John ...Read More »
• ### EGG— EGGS– EGGS

We have an egg problem again. There is a 36 story building for which you have complete access. You have ...Read More »
• ### Proposal offer riddle

A 15-year footballer John was offered a contract with a club name “Football” that if he will practice 1 hour ...Read More »
• ### Get out of mansion puzzle

You’re in a mansion and the power’s out. You see a green door and a red door.  Pick one (it ...Read More »
• ### Touching Calender Funny puzzle

When I touch this year’s calendar, I get a shock. Why?Read More »
• ### See how the outer rings appear to rotate?

Look at the red dot in the middle and move your head towards and away from the screen. See how ...Read More »
• ### Not for reading or writing

Which type of paper can not be used whether for reading or for writing ?Read More »
• ### Number Riddle

Replace the question mark with the correct number in the below-given picture?Read More »
• ### Math teacher funny puzzle

What kind of tree does a math teacher climb?Read More »
• ### Talking without Word

How can one talk without saying a single word?Read More »
• ### Runs but never flee

It runs but can never flee. It is often watched, yet never sees. When long it brings boredom, When short ...Read More »
• ### Cards Probability Puzzle

Andrew is shuffling a pack of 54 cards in total and after some time, he takes out a joker card. ...Read More »