Two Children Puzzle
I ask people at random if they have two children and also if one is a boy born on a tuesday. After a long search I finally find someone who answers yes.
What is the probability that this person has two boys?
Assume an equal chance of giving birth to either sex and an equal chance to giving birth on any day.
1/2.
The person already had 1 boy. So the chance of other child to be a boy is 1/2 .
13/27.
There are 14 different combinations of {gender,day}. So for a family of two as you describe, there are 196 possible combinations.
However, only 27 of them include a boy who was born on a Tuesday. In 14, the older child fits the description and the younger is any of the others. In 14, the younger fits and the older is any of the others. Since one combination got counted twice, there are 14+14-1=27.
Similarly, 7+7-1=13 have two boys.
Since a parent who answers “yes” to your question is equally likely to have any of these combinations, the answer is 13/27.
But your version isn’t how this puzzle originated. At a math-puzzle convention, a man named Gary Foshee announced “I have two children, and one of them is a boy who was born on a Tuesday.” He then asked for the same probability that he did. He said the answer was 13/27, but it really is 1/2.
Why is it not the same question? Because is all but the one case where he has two Tuesday boys, he could have formulated his question in two possible ways. We can only assume he chose randomly, so we can only count half of the cases where that was possible. The answer [(13+13)/2+1]/[(6+6)/2+1]=14/7=1/2.
This is the same logic that (correctly) solves the Monty Hall Problem, and the Bertrand Box Problem.
And the similar problem “You know that a certain woman has two children and at least one boy. What are the chances she has two boys?” Answer: 1/2, not 1/3.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
Strawberry Jam Puzzle
The Smith family is a very wealthy family that lives in a big circular home. One morning, Mr Smith woke ...Read More »Where do fish keep their money?
Where do fish keep their money?Read More »40 Elephants having forty-four heads funny riddle
In a pond, there were forty elephants.Those elephants had forty-fore heads. How can this be feasible in real world?Read More »You want me and also don\’t want me riddle
When you don\’t have me, you want me, but when you do have me, you want to give me away. ...Read More »Orange distribution tricky puzzle
A basket containing twenty Oranges is with you. You have twenty members in your family, each desire an orange. You ...Read More »Guess What It Says
Can you guess what does below rebus says?Read More »Who Broke The Pot?
Three friends Jim, Sam and Tom were playing in the garden and one of them broke a pot. While enquiring ...Read More »Man in New York City with 10 Dollars puzzle
A man in New York City has $10. He spends $6.50 on flowers, and $3 on lunch (hot coffee and ...Read More »Word does not belong with the others
Which word does NOT belong with the others? A. index B. glossary C. chapter D. bookRead More »Romans Castle Brain Twister
Once upon a time, there was a castle on a square island. The entire island was surrounded by a 14m ...Read More »How many have 28 puzzle
It’s February. Some months have 30 days, some months have 31 days. How many have 28?Read More »Maths Odd One Out
Which Number is the odd one out? A) 7145 B) 2716 C) 5321 D) 4135Read More »What is the code ?
A man desired to get into his work building, however he had forgotten his code. However, he did recollect five ...Read More »Apple on Demand Puzzle
An apple seller is hosting a competition. He offers 1000 apples and 10 boxes to the people who pass by. ...Read More »Orange in the Basket riddle
Five oranges are in a basket. How do you divide them among five Boys so that each Boy gets an ...Read More »How do i survive after elevator crash puzzle
A lift is on the ground floor. There are 4 people in the lift including me. When the lift reaches ...Read More »Quick Eye test riddle
Just do it, do not cheat! Because of you did, this test would be no fun. We promise that there ...Read More »Together they are brother riddle
He always follow his brother, although very different they are. You can see one, but not other. You can hear ...Read More »Replace the question mark
The below-given figure comprises a pattern through which you can determine the missing letter. Can you push your mind to ...Read More »Sundar Pichai Birthday puzzle, How come?
One day Sundar Pichai celebrated his birthday. Two days later his older twin brother, Larry, celebrated his birthday. How come? ...Read More »