Two Children Puzzle
I ask people at random if they have two children and also if one is a boy born on a tuesday. After a long search I finally find someone who answers yes.
What is the probability that this person has two boys?
Assume an equal chance of giving birth to either sex and an equal chance to giving birth on any day.
1/2.
The person already had 1 boy. So the chance of other child to be a boy is 1/2 .
13/27.
There are 14 different combinations of {gender,day}. So for a family of two as you describe, there are 196 possible combinations.
However, only 27 of them include a boy who was born on a Tuesday. In 14, the older child fits the description and the younger is any of the others. In 14, the younger fits and the older is any of the others. Since one combination got counted twice, there are 14+14-1=27.
Similarly, 7+7-1=13 have two boys.
Since a parent who answers “yes” to your question is equally likely to have any of these combinations, the answer is 13/27.
But your version isn’t how this puzzle originated. At a math-puzzle convention, a man named Gary Foshee announced “I have two children, and one of them is a boy who was born on a Tuesday.” He then asked for the same probability that he did. He said the answer was 13/27, but it really is 1/2.
Why is it not the same question? Because is all but the one case where he has two Tuesday boys, he could have formulated his question in two possible ways. We can only assume he chose randomly, so we can only count half of the cases where that was possible. The answer [(13+13)/2+1]/[(6+6)/2+1]=14/7=1/2.
This is the same logic that (correctly) solves the Monty Hall Problem, and the Bertrand Box Problem.
And the similar problem “You know that a certain woman has two children and at least one boy. What are the chances she has two boys?” Answer: 1/2, not 1/3.
Your Answer
More puzzles to try-
cities without houses
Where can we find roads without cars, forests without trees and cities without houses ?Read More »What is the chance that the last passenger will get his seat?
There are 100 passengers boarding a 100 passenger airplane. When passenger 1 gets onto the plane, he is dissoriented, so ...Read More »Where is the father right now?
Mom is 21 years older than her son. In 6 years she will be 5 times older than her son. ...Read More »How will you Market your product?
How will you sell a Refrigerator to an Eskimo?Read More »Commander order
A group of soldiers were standing in the blistering sun facing west. Their commander shouted at them: Right turn! About ...Read More »Math teacher funny puzzle
What kind of tree does a math teacher climb?Read More »When is Cheryl’s Birthday?
Albert and Bernard just became friends with Cheryl, and they want to know when her birthday is. Cheryl gives them ...Read More »Rich man’s and gold Coin puzzle
A rich man died. In his will, he has divided his gold coins among his 5 sons, 5 daughters and ...Read More »How will you make everyone happy?
You are driving down the road in your car on a thunder and stormy night. You saw three people waiting ...Read More »Complete this 6 letter word – _ h _ a _ t
Complete this 6 letter word – _ h _ a _ t Clues- 1. Girls love it. 2. Boys like ...Read More »A man with a car riddle
A man with a car on his head is called…….Read More »Massage Parlour
Outside a massage parlour, there is a board that reads “I only massage those who do not massage themselves.” Reading ...Read More »2 is called 10
When we see 2 but call 10?Read More »Typewritter Riddle
Customer services at Puzzlefry headquarters received the following letter yesterday. Our top puzzle solvers were able to determine the meaning ...Read More »What is the smallest time interval that can be measured?
You are given some matches, a rope, and a pair of scissors. The rope burns irregularly and takes 60 minutes ...Read More »How to find the correct label by checking only one basket
There are three baskets labeled Orange , Apple, Oracle/Apple. And all of them have wrong labels.How to find the correct ...Read More »How long will it take for water to hit his house?
A man built his house above a river between two trees. He attaches his house to the middle of the ...Read More »Help me find the missing number for the 0
4 6 2 9 0 1 19 10 0 6 0 31 0 0 8 6 2 9 1 19 ...Read More »Animals in a Zoo
If a zookeeper had 100 pairs of animals in her zoo, and two pairs of babies are born for each ...Read More »Born out of water puzzle
I am born out of water And live on land Touch of my mother Brings demise on hand. Who am ...Read More »