The missing penny


Here is an ancient puzzle that has always perplexed some people. Two market women were selling their apples, one at three for a penny and the other at two for a penny. One day they were both called away when each had thirty apples unsold: these they handed to a friend to sell at five for 2¢. It will be seen that if they had sold their apples separately they would have fetched 25¢, but when they were sold together they fetched only 24¢.
“Now,” people ask, “what in the world has become of that missing penny?” because, it is said, three for l¢ and two for l¢ is surely exactly the same as five for 2¢.
Can you explain the little mystery?

Add Comment

  • 1 Answer(s)

    The explanation is simply this. The two ways of selling are only identical when the number of apples sold at three for a penny and two for a penny is
    in the proportion of three to two.  Thus, if the first woman had handed over 36 apples, and the second woman  24, they would have fetched 24¢, whether sold separately or at five for 2¢.  But if they each held the same number of apples there would be a loss when sold together of l¢ in every 60 apples. So if they had 60 each there would be a loss of2¢. If there were 180 apples (90 each) they would lose 3¢, and so on.  The missing penny in the case of 60 arises from the fact that the three a penny woman gains 2¢, and the two a penny woman loses 3¢.  Perhaps the fairest practical division of the 24¢ would be that the first woman receives 9.5¢ and the second woman 14.5 , so that each loses 0.5¢ on the transaction.

    ravi Expert Answered on 30th July 2015.
    Add Comment
  • Your Answer

    By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.
  • More puzzles to try-