Home

THE POTATO PARADOX

1,610.1K Views

Imagine that a farmer has a sack containing 100 lbs of potatoes. The potatoes, he discovers, are comprised of 99% water and 1% solids, so he leaves them in the heat of the sun for a day to let the amount of water in them reduce to 98%. But when he returns to them the day after, he finds his 100 lb sack now weighs just 50 lbs. How can this be true? Well, if 99% of 100 lbs of potatoes is water then the water must weigh 99 lbs. The 1% of solids must ultimately weigh just 1 lb, giving a ratio of solids to liquids of 1:99. But if the potatoes are allowed to dehydrate to 98% water, the solids must now account for 2% of the weight—a ratio of 2:98, or 1:49—even though the solids must still only weigh 1lb. The water, ultimately, must now weigh 49lb, giving a total weight of 50lbs despite just a 1% reduction in water content. Or must it?

Although not a true paradox in the strictest sense, the counterintuitive Potato Paradox is a famous example of what is known as a veridical paradox, in which a basic theory is taken to a logical but apparently absurd conclusion.

Share
John123 Expert Asked on 31st July 2015 in Unsolved Puzzles.
Add Comment
Cancel

    • 1 Answer(s)

    There is no paradox here, or anything even close.

    At 99 pounds water and 1 pound solids, the water is 99/(99+1) = 99% by weight of the potatoes.

    Removing 1% of the water (0.99 pounds) makes the ratio of solids be 98.01/(98.01+1) = 98.99% by weight of the potatoes.  (Or, removing water equivalent to 1% of the weight of the potatoes makes the ratio of solids be 98/(98+1) = 98.9899% by weight.)  This amounts to reducing the quantity of water by 1% (or 1 pound), but reducing the ratio of the water by just 0.01% (or 0.010101…%).

    The potential confusion results from linguistics, not math.  It has to do with the two different uses of the word “percentage”.

    Let’s look at another example.  Let’s say that 99% of 100 people surveyed like ice cream, leaving one person (1%) of people that don’t like ice cream.  To reduce the percentage of people that like ice cream to 98%, just 1% (one person) needs to join the group of people that don’t like ice cream, making 2% of people not like ice cream.  However, if instead of an ice cream fan converting I simply eliminate one person that likes ice cream from the survey, instead of 2% of people not liking ice cream, there are just 1.01%.

    Cancel
    dougbell Genius Answered on 22nd October 2015.
    Add Comment
    Cancel

    • Your Answer

    By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

  • More puzzles to try-

  • Accenture Interview PuzzlesAdobe Interview PuzzlesAge RiddleAkbar Birbal PuzzlesAlgorithm PuzzlesAlphabet riddleAmazon Interview PuzzlesAnalytical MathematicsAptitude PuzzleBank PuzzlesBetting PuzzlesBrain TeasersCalendar PuzzlesCards PuzzlesChess Board PuzzleChess PuzzlesChristmas Puzzlecipher PuzzleCivil Services PuzzleClock time puzzleCognizant Interview PuzzlesCoins PuzzleComputational PuzzleconundrumCoronavirus PuzzleCoupondunia Interview PuzzleCritical Thinking Puzzledata analyticsData Structure Interview QuestionsDecode PuzzleDetective PuzzlesDice PuzzleDictionary Riddlesdifficult riddleEasy Math puzzlesEasy puzzlesEinstein puzzleEnglish RiddleFamily Tree Puzzlefamous puzzleFill in the blanks riddlesFinding Killer RiddlesFlipkart interview puzzlesFunny RiddlesGeneral KnowledgeGeographical PuzzleGoogle Code Jam 2014Google Interview PuzzlesGRE PuzzleHard Puzzle