How did the police know the murderer?

1,245.2K Views

One night, a man receives a call from the Police. The Police tell the man that his wife was murdered, and that he should reach the crime scene as soon as possible. The man drops the phone, shocked, and drives 20 minutes to the crime scene. As soon as he reaches the crime scene, the police arrest him for the murder.

How did the police know that he committed the crime?

Some added notes of mine to avoid this being too broad:

– The man is not covered in blood. There is no trace of his wife’s blood on him, his car, his possessions, etc.
– The man’s car is not dented from hitting his wife.
– There is no evidence of foul play on the man or his possessions.
– Aliens are not involved. Neither is an unlimited amount of rope, or other unconventional murder weapons.
-These are typical, just perhaps clever detectives. They have no extra-sensory abilities, super strength, mind-reading, gift of flight, x-ray vision, etc.
– The man didn’t say a word when he reached the crime scene. He also didn’t commit any crime on the way to or at the crime scene. The police moved in to arrest him the moment they spotted his car.

Share
Add Comment

  • 2 Answer(s)

    The obvious answer is that the police did not tell him where the wife was murdered but he reached the site.

    SherlockHolmes Expert Answered on 25th July 2015.
    Add Comment

    The obvious answer- or, rather,the ‘obvious question’ – of how did the man know the crime scene without the police telling him actually has a perfectly logical and practically possible answer, which can put the police action under cloud. Consider the following scenario:

    Let’s call the man Mr. John. Mrs. John had gone visiting her parents who are living in the neighbouring city. Naturally, Mr. John knows where she has gone, and which route she has / might have taken, how far she could have traveled etc. So, when he gets the call from the Police informing about the murder, he takes off on the same route and reaches the crime scene which he can identify without trouble thanks to the presence of police, cordoned off site etc. He’s perfectly innocent, having never even thought of killing his wife in the  wildest of dreams, yet ends up in custody…!

    Viji_Pinarayi Expert Answered on 20th November 2015.
    Add Comment
  • Your Answer

    By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.
  • More puzzles to try-